"A captain's job is a lonely one. He's easily misunderstood."

On this episode, we welcome back John Arminio and his father, Captain Tom Arminio, USN, Retired, to tackle a double feature of classic WWII-set Naval melodramas: 1954's The Caine Mutiny and 1955's Mister Roberts. Both films deal with the tricky subject of bad military leadership, how it trickles down the ranks and threatens the effectiveness of an entire ship. Whose is the worst captain, Humphrey Bogart's erratic and incompetent Queeg or James Cagney's oppressive and oblivious Morton? When is the right time for officers to take a stand against a potentially mad or tyrannical leader? When is the right time to pitch the palm tree into the ocean?

Organizing movie screenings and discussions with his geographically separated family during the height of the pandemic, John Arminio has enjoyed regular movie talks with his father, whose 24 years of Naval experience give him a unique insight into these depictions of faulty leadership on the decks of wartime ships.

Support our Patreon: www.patreon.com/thepinksmoke

The Pink Smoke site: www.thepinksmoke.com

The Pink Smoke on Twitter: twitter.com/thepinksmoke

John Arminio on Twitter: twitter.com/QuasarSniffer

John Cribbs on Twitter: twitter.com/TheLastMachine

Intro music: Unleash the Bastards / “Tea for Two” Outro music: Marcus Pinn / “Vegas”

Broadcast on:

07 Dec 2021