BiKitzur Shulchan Aruch
Ep. 849. What Is the Correct Brocha to Make on Fruit Soups?
What Is the Correct Brocha to Make on Fruit Soups?
Welcome everybody, shear number 849, getting back to our hilca's brochos. Okay, I just want to, while we spoke about, started talking a little bit about soups. Last shear, even though it was more with a reference to mezoanos, barley, and noodles. I just want to go through a few soups while we are in the subject of soups. We spoke about a while back, but just to review real quickly, for example, like fruit soups. That's not a regular fruit soup. What's that like with a regular fruit soup? And the fruit soup, let's say, cherries, peaches, plums, it's a fruit soup. Right? So, in general, the halacha is, just to read from about in the say from page 437, he's actually quoting the mishabura, not in our sim and raishreas, but it's in sim and raish baiz, raish baiz, subkottunun dalad. So he says like this, for fruit soups, fruit soups containing solid pieces of fruit, right? One should make a brochah for the fruit, which will exempt the liquid in the soup, right? For example, if somebody has a soup made from cherries, peaches, plums, or so on, one should make a boiré pre-heart eights, right? And this is what he quotes from the mishabura in them, just to read real quickly to lesson mishabura, and sifkottunun dalad in sim and raish baiz, ahvel, im ukhul, peris, ahtsman, I'll show you some. I am Gamm, kind of person's eating the fruits that are in the fruit soup, and they're drinking together. They're taking the juices from the soup, mrabidil, kuliyama, according to everybody in circle of arkalim, la brochah, we're sharing with la brochah, karina. In other words, on the drink itself, the juice itself, the soup itself, you don't have to make a brochah, because it's all tough to the fruit, someone would just make a brochah pre-eights, which would cover everything, ah, but then he goes on to save him, it could cover not a fish real on mine, but if the person has in mind the soup, the soup, for arkal is in their peris, mrila, then they make a brochah pre-eights, then he says, "Sarina, sallamur, kshah, kul," then it could be problematic if you have to make a shahakul. In other words, my main purpose of the soup is the soup, right? So, the fruits are whatever, it's sort of on the side, if you want to call it, then it brings down, one should make, in that case, you make a brochah pre-eights, so you take out a, you take a couple of fruits, right, from the fruit soup, you make a brochah pre-eights, but then, one should take something else, mrabidil says, valqing, broch, albohr, arkar, the hila, shahakul, somebody should, the person should take something else out, I'm sorry, not something else, they should take something else, alqing, yavir, albohr, arkar, the hila, and make a shahakul, something else, right, you take either a pinch of salt, you take a pinch of sugar, you take a piece of chocolate, whatever, something else, make a shahakul. So, that's what Rabadna brings down, again, in the safe of page 437, if one wishes to eat the liquid without the fruit, they should make a shahakul, so, okay, it's actually two separate cases, Rabadna is talking about, in the case, it was also brought down the shalhana, if somebody wishes to, I want to eat the liquid from the soup, that's what I want, right, so then they should first, then they should take a make a shahakul, and you make a hua, ate separately, you take out, but you pull out, take out a fruit separately, the case of misha bruh is talking about, it's more like, if a person wants more, they want the fruit, in other words, their fruit soup is really for the, it could govern us a bishqil maim, it's really for the juices that they have it, and that's the main reason why they're eating it, so then, that becomes more problematic, so that's why he says, therefore, to make a shahakul on something else, he says, first, al daba acha trilah, make a shahakul on something else, like we said, candy, chocolate, whatever, on something else first, and, okay, now the reason, the reason why we say, in general, we have this concept, sometimes, the reason why we say to make a shahakul first, we saw it by other things also, is that, because it could be, it could be, I'm not going to get into the homah like it's not, but it could be that if you make the burp reaits already, it's sort of, you covered, you really covered the whole soup, because, lemise, it's a fruit soup, but, but I, this person's kavanas for the water, for the soup, but that's what he wants, so it becomes a ready question, we'll definitely make a shahakul first, and then, but make sure you eat a piece of fruit, you take out, you can take out a piece of fruit, you take out a piece of to a fruit, you make a burp reaits separately, make a burp reaits separately, and then you're good to go, like this, you know, you covered all grounds, okay, so that's that, and like we said, as far as Rabban, what he's saying is plain and simple, if somebody wishes to drink the liquid without the fruit, obviously then one would make a shahakul, that's a separate thing, okay, but, I just want to make it clear, we have an understanding, I'm eating a regular fruit soup, I eat it together, this is my fruit soup, so in general one makes a burp reait, it's only cases we spoke about, those exceptions, then, then we, a little bit change it, but regular fruit soup, I'm eating it together, cherries, peaches, plums, whatever the case is, I would make a burp reait, okay, now what about, what about, he goes on to say further, I get this simple ik of a tuffle halakhas, which we spoke about in the past, what about if somebody's eating a fruit soup and then has some burp reaits, and some burp reait dhamma, how do we work that, if the soup, he continues on containing fruits of a tree and fruits from the ground, which would be burp reait dhamma from the ground, and from the tree, obviously burp reaits, well we'll make a brocha on the majority, right, I'm eating it together, I'm eating scoop, scoop, spoon, after spoon, so then we go after the majority, simple halakhas of ik of a tuffle to illustrate, he gives an example, if the soup contains a majority, not counting the liquid, we're talking about, right, we don't mix the liquid, you can eat the liquid also, that's not the issue, but we're counting, we're looking at is it more ha-eights or is it more hoa dhamma, so if the soup contains a majority of fruits from the ground, for example pineapple, strawberries, in case sometimes strawberries would check the right way, you have to be careful with strawberries, but be it as it may, it has items in it that is hoa dhamma, right, and the majority are the ha-dhamma fruits, and then you have also possibly plum speeches, whatever, but that's the minority, the smaller amount, then the brocha will be burait pre hoa dhamma, because that's simple ik of a tuffle, every spoonful I go by the majority, whatever is more, that's the brocha that I make, okay, then he goes on, he just finishes off, in either case, the fruit from a tree, whether the fruit, and the same thing the other way, if you have the burait, the fruit from a tree is more, so then I'll make a burait pre eights, as long as I eat it all together, now what about the liquid in those cases, right, in either case he goes on to say, whether the fruit of the ground is more, whether the burait pre hoa dhamma is more, I'll make hoa dhamma, if the burait pre eights is what, make burait pre eights, but the liquid of the soup itself, which is eaten together, if the fruit is exempt by the brocha made on the fruit, okay, so that's whether it's hoa dhamma and the hoa dhamma is more, the liquid is all inclusive in that, if it's burait pre eights, and the burait pre eights is more, then the liquid is all inclusive in that, and I would not need it need, I would not need a separate characle in conjunction, unless it was one of the exceptions that we spoke about in the beginning of the sheer, okay, we'll stop over here, thank you for listening us, locha and brocha, coltive.