BiKitzur Shulchan Aruch
Ep. 845. If One Is Eating Grapes Together with Other Types of Fruits (e.g., Apples, Oranges, etc.), How Do We Handle the After Brocha?
If One Is Eating Grapes Together with Other Types of Fruits (e.g., Apples, Oranges, etc.), How Do We Handle the After Brocha?
Welcome everybody, share number 845, getting back to our hlokas preachos. Okay, so we are in the middle of our Cimmon-Rege-Rez-Rez, we're trying to go through the various different halakhas. There are many, many extremely important, all halakhas are important, but very negaled. If you want to call them a lot of practical applications which come out of the various different halakhas brought down in Cimmon-Rege-Rez, that's why I take a little bit of a longer time, but we're trying to cover as much ground as we could with practical applications with the help of a cottage borchor, of course. So in the Simurech class, again, she's jumping around a little bit because we want to see little bits here, little bits there. So the Mahabud, the Shlokhanarach and Sif, your gimel, sense a very important thing. Somebody actually asks, "You're eating grapes, persons eating grapes, right? They're eating fruits from the Shavasamin, whereby they're going to require the Brakhav al-Hawait, the Brakhav, the after Brakh on fruits from the Shavasamin. Let's say, for example, somebody eats grapes and they eat the right amount. We're not getting into all that again. We spoke about that in the past, but they eat the right amount, let's say. So not have to make a brokh, but you don't make a bernafosh, so on grapes you get to make a al-Hawait for pre-await, right? So now the question is, so that's not what we're trying to bring out today, but the question is today, "Good, I'm eating my grapes, a whole bunch of grapes, enough to make an al-Hawait, to make an after Brakh." But I'm also eating other fruits. I'm eating an apple, right? I'm eating an orange also. The person sits down and they're going to eat quite a number of fruits, and there is the grapes and other fruits too. So the al-Hawait's have to make and I have to make a bernafosh, but maybe we're going to say that I make only the al-Hawait and the al-Hawait's will cover all the other fruits. Okay. What about if I'm eating vegetables, right? I ate tomatoes. Let's say tomatoes. "Good, I ate the grapes. I'm going to make my al-Hawait and I ate some tomatoes." Tomatoes have to make a bernafosh, right? Would that be good? "I ate an apple. I ate an orange." It's not from the shivis aminum. As we know, apple and orange are not from the fruits we're by making al-Hawait's. If somebody eats an apple, right, you eat a full apple, then actually make a bernafosh. It's, of course, as long as they ate at the right amount of time, you make a bernafosh. What about if somebody drank fruit juices? Let's say I drank apple juice, regular plain apple juice, in which case you would make a bernafosh, would that fall under the al-Hawait's also? And what about all other fruits? I ate some meat. I ate some kugel, you know, or something like that. We're by the bernafosh. In the case in time, kugel, let's say potato kugel or whatever the case is. Okay. So that's the question now. How do we work this? How do we look at it? Okay, so number one, we establish the fact that you make an al-Hawait on grapes, assuming a person ate the right amount. So now the question is, so says the Mahabhar, interesting, how local that in also pairs me ship some medium, somebody ate the fruits from the shivers some medium, but also in which case they have to make a al-Hawait, the air of the brotha would be al-Hawait, right? They ate the right amount, it has to be al-Hawait, but also the poocum. They also ate some apples, right? They ate an apple. So what do I do? So ainsarach tells us the Mahabhar straight up al-Hawait, ainsarach levarach al-Hawait a poocum, bernafoshis. In that case you would not, and you ate it at the same time, obviously, you would not make ainsarach levarach al-Hawait a poocum, bernafoshis, one would not make a bernafoshis on the apple. Why? Shigam haim bachal al-Hawait, because in effect when somebody makes a al-Hawait, well, pretty way it's to make the air of the brotha of al-Hawait, on the grapes, I'm just giving an example, it could be with other one of the shivers, the medium also, right? So now he says, shigam haim, I think grapes is a very popular thing, that's why that's something that people eat all the time. Shigam haim bachal al-Hawait, it's a fall under the apple, would also fall under the air of the brotha. Shigam haim bachal al-Hawait, I'm sorry, shigam haim pre-hawait, haim, this is also from the pre, it's also from the fruit, it's sort of like the same family as the grapes, but it's not as different air of the brotha. Okay, it's very similar, let's go like that. Avilim al-Hawait a poocum, but now the question is, if somebody ate, was eating good, like ate the grapes, I have to make all the ates. And I'm eating a poocum, I'm eating also the apples. Vishosa yayen, and now I drank wine, right, I drank grape juice, and I drank enough whereby I have to make al-Hawait gefem haapriya gefen. Sorek levar ech bernafushes, then one, oh, so, so now again, you're not eating grapes, a different case again. I'm eating, I'm eating an apple, and I'm drinking wine. Forget the grapes for now, we'll get back to that, but I'm eating an apple, and I'm drinking wine. So, says the macabre den vishosa yayen, sorek levar ech bernafushes, one would have to make it bernafushes al-Hawait a poocum on the apples. In that case, it's only over there whereby you're making an al-Hawait on the grapes whereby it would cover something in the shivers, something in making al-Hait, it would cover the apple, but if you're drinking wine, and you're making it, even though it's a brotha, brotha haapriya gefen. As we know, right, it's a, it's a, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the zonos, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the fruits from the shivers, you're making al-Hawait a poocum on wine, and grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum, you make al-Hawait a poocum, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make al-Hawait a poocum on the grapes, you make