BiKitzur Shulchan Aruch
Ep. 862. If One Makes a Bracha on Fruit in the Middle of a Meal When They Washed for Bread and Then They Went Out: When They Come Back, Do They Need a New Bracha?
If One Makes a Bracha on Fruit in the Middle of a Meal When They Washed for Bread and Then They Went Out: When They Come Back, Do They Need a New Bracha?
Welcome everybody it's your number 862 getting back to our hilghasparathas. So interesting concept we spoke about last time if somebody's eating cake together with coffee right so they're now and now they have to leave they leave the building whatever the case is when they come back so since they have the cake the cake is not finished what they didn't make in Allah (M) even though the cake might be finished so what's happening is this they established the Kavias and the Kavias would go also on the coffee even though in general again what's the law we know in general the prison drinking a coffee playing coffee and they have to go out outside the building right even for a very short period of time a few seconds or whatever the case might be but that once they have to go out they come back a new brotha is needed on that same cup of coffee and even if they took continue to take the coffee with them okay but be it as a may but if they let's say the eating cake and coffee right or some type of muzonos and they go out then so on the muzonos you don't have to make a new brotha we said less but on the coffee you would have to make but since you have the muzonos with it eating it together in general it's one established thing if you want to call it the Kavias was formed and it stays until a person would make the alhammaqia on the cake so what I wanted to talk about which is even more more of a dove of posh it but it wasn't such a dove of posh it when I first thought about it when I heard the question from one of our one of our banecha bura it was nice enough to ask us the question so the question is like this I'm eating I sit down to eat a meal right or I'm at a sudah I'm at a sudah I'm at a brotha shabbos whatever the case might be and I washed and everything wonderful now I start to eat dessert right so for desserts I'm eating fruits and as we know if somebody's eating fruit for dessert you have to make a brotha right if I have some some even apple for dessert right even though I washed and even though I had it in mind it doesn't make a difference the apple one has to make a brotha on the apple or any anything else chocolate whatever the case is in general desserts fruits chocolates candies these oldest different type of things one would have to make a brotha even though they washed off so now the question is like this good I'm eating I'm eating fruits and I'm in the middle of eating my my fruits and now but now I had to run out in other words if I'm by a meal it's like this if I'm by a meal I washed right so if a person has to go out for whatever reason they have to go out so when they come back we discussed in the past better not to go out to bench first okay but be it as it may that's not the issue right now the question is if for whatever reason the person had to go out to do a mitzvah or something and they watched so when they come back you don't have to you don't have to make a new brotha there's no new homoitzi because by homoitzi there's no there's no shina makkam and by miso knows there's no shina makkam right shina makkam and grape juice all that and wine we spoke about as a makk like it's not going to go through that again right now but be it as it may so good so I don't have to remake the brotha I had to go out of my house to do something right real quickly and I came back so for the homoitzi I don't have to make a new brotha but now the question is I started eating fruits for the fruits and I made the brotha right I made my birth creates I started eating an apple an orange whatever the case is and that's my fruit so I made my brotha which you have to make a fruit in the middle of the meal but now the question is once I made the berpria 8 I'm in the middle of a fruit and I had to go out now that I came back in right a new homoitzi I don't have to make to it but do I have to make a new berpria 8 for the fruit because what do you mean fruit is shina makkam so the answer is no a person would not have to make a new a person would not have to make a new berpria 8 even though on fruits we say it's shina makkam and if somebody just sits down to eat an apple or an orange or something like that and they go out just dumb without washing right and now when they come back they go out of the house again we're talking about clearly when the person leak goes out of the house even for a short period of time you have to be extremely careful with these things sometimes you know UPS or whatever you have to take the child off the bus whatever the case might be you have to be very careful once you go out you sort of stock you need a new brotha when you come back okay it's a little bit of makkalikis if it's only for like a second or two some say to make a brotha and something else but according to the michiburo for sure and according to major place came you would have to remake the brotha so now but the questions but since but now the the answer to our question is since you're ready washed and the kaviyas was there in other words you establish the place right there's no there's no shina makkam on the bread so just like by the cake which we saw last time the cake in coffee right the person comes back in you don't have to make a new brotha the coffee and the cake for sure not you went out of the house you come back you have to make a new brotha you do not have to make a new brotha the coffee on the cake and not on the coffee so kal bakhaima for sure if somebody washed right so but it I just wanted to bring that point out it's important that we have this in mind so for sure if somebody washed and they established a place by eating bread and I was talking about clear it took a day at least sick as eyes of bread because like we said if somebody did not eat it because eyes of bread we keep on clustering over and reviewing these halocas because they're so important and they come up on a daily basis mamash on a daily basis people bhaksham doesn't hate we should all be able to eat every day three times a day right some people eat for more but but be it as a may we're constantly eating some people washing not washing whatever the case is but we have to know these column these are these are the the most simplest not the most simplest but the basic column of halocas brahas if you don't eat the cuz eyes of bread you did the and now you go out you come back you have to remake a mighty and you have to re-wash probably without a braha to re-wash without a natal sedombia would we have to make a mighty and if you don't need a cuz eyes of mazonos you go out and now you come back you would have to remake them the mazonos and if you and let's just go back to the case from last from yesterday if you did not eat a cuz eyes of cake and now you went out so and and you took a sip at a coffee right you took a little bite of cake not a cuz eyes less than a cuz eyes and a little bite of cake you made mazonos and you drank a drop at a coffee whatever the case is now you come back you have to make a braha again on both look over you have to make a braha again on both on the cake because you never established the place you never ate a cuz eyes of cake and you have to make a braha on the and you would have to make a new shahakal on the coffee so that's important thing also to keep in mind sometimes it happens a person takes a little bite they make a mazonos little bite they took a little sip at a coffee whatever they'd made a shahakal and then they had to run out now you came back again you stuck because two brahas are needed so one has to be very careful the same thing with a mochi but assuming that you ate the cuz eyes and now you're up to dessert let's say and you're and you're or even not up to dessert the middle of the meal the eating fruits you made a braha braha pre-heated now you go out so when you come back right you come back I'm assuming short a period of time we're talking about obviously you come back so a new braha pre-heated would not have to be made since the person ate a cuz eyes of the bread and they established the place and they are and and they did not bench yet that's the other point they did not bench yet so although they made a braha pre-heated on the apple orange or whatever before that right before they went out now when they came back they would not have to remake another braha pre-heated because it sort of schlips after the bread until after brahas a mazen until after the bench thank you for listening us welcome