Rabbi Joey Soffer Shiurim
Neighbors 51-shared expenses 3
Good morning everybody August 27th. Okay. Yeah, I'll page one or nine. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I'll go back to the next interview. I know I'm obligated to pay. I can't afford it right now. For me the money, I'm going to pay you. No problem, fine. So I'm in front of the money and I'll pay over time. That's okay. He has the money. I'm out, I'm not paying. Oh, you know what, I'm fine, no problem. We'll take care of it, Mr. Bettine. They're bringing over here two big jazz guys. They pick them up, they throw them out of his house. They rent the house out and they take the money. So I guess they're early at education. Yeah, I know, it's not. Education is not a requirement that can be a communal, especially in those days. You will obligate to teach your own son. School was instituted later on. We learned it back back, if you remember. The expense of educating your child is your personal expense. It's not a communal expense. You have an obligation to teach your son. Right? So that's not a communal expense. So, we're doing our communal expenses. We live together over here. I need to fix this, whatever the story is. The lock to the courtyard is broken. I gotta call the locksmith. We all have to share the expense. Oh, you know, I'm not paying, you're not paying? Okay, no problem. Call the Bettine, take care of it. Okay, fine. Now, on the bottom. Is it all you're ready? Yeah, la. On the right hand side on the bottom. So when we said in, where was this in Halacha? A bit, right? I think it was in Alif, where was it? Alif a bit. Oh, this is the guy who doesn't live there, right? When you said if you're not living in the apartment, you don't live there, you're on the property, and you rented it out or whatever the story is. It's not even empty. It's my house, right? It's my deal house. And since I'm not there, it says that I only have to pay for security. I don't have to pay for anything else. What's not paid for anything else? It says on the bottom. On the right hand side. I don't have to pay for the lock. You want me to pay for the door? I got it. The guy, you want to get a security guard? Okay. Fine. I'm not. Let him stay in that side. Because I can have security without it. You guys want to be very nice to your security guard. You want the guy to stand there to stand there to stand there to have a nice air condition, a little booth? Good luck. Let him stay in that side. Can't force me. I don't live there. Okay. Now that time that they're there, why? They bet you I'm going to be talking to Zechri. Ah, beautiful. What's the reason for this guard house over there? It says the issue really is that you have to realize that we learned it, I think, way, way back before. Maybe even the beginning, maybe the first class, maybe. Zechri means that, you know, there's an issue of privacy, right? But my house, my courtyard is open to the public area. So I have privacy issues. I don't want the public people staring into my lawn, looking what I'm doing inside there, look at that. So I build a bit shot. I build a guard house to block the vintage, the line of sight from the chutella beam. All right? So I don't have to do that. I'm not. Why don't I have to contribute? Well, because I don't live there. They're not damaging me. They're damaging you guys who are in the courtyard. I don't know. My house is empty. I live in Brooklyn. I'm not. So you can't force me to pay for that. Okay? To put the lock, to put the guard, to put that. Yes, you can, but to put, to stop me, the public from looking into the courtyard. I don't care if they look at the courtyard, I'm not there. First to me. Okay, fine. Same to say. Put, put, put, put, put a door. That's not secret if you want. I don't get what you want from me. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. So that was a question now. So now if he shows that it's nice, that he's happy with that, now we make a pay, right? Okay. Left hand side. Lefis Mamon. We said also before that when we, let's say we're going to put the guard at the courtyard and we're going to assess everybody based on their ability to pay. The guy who has more money has to pay more for the guard, then the guy who has less money. All right. So that's the security guys going down the blocks. And by us, let's say, assuming that we can equate that to a courtyard. It's not really a courtyard. It's more of a public area. But fine. How are we paying for this guy? Based on, based on ability to pay. Okay. Now, the Af says the Mishpat ulim on the left side. The Af, the Bechah, Umi Shum, is equal. Yeah. Even though we just explained that the, the guard house itself would be blocking the vision from the shooting department. It's because of the privacy issues. The Muhakmikand is equal. This is the source that we say that it is considered damage when the shooting that I've been people are looking into my area or people are looking into my privacy. I mean, privacy issues is considered real damage. Fine. Muhakmikand ulim on the right side. I mean, if I feel really actually I had Pishnaim, when it comes to his privacy. Now, do I assess privacy based on ability to pay? Or is privacy equal to every single person? All right. You're telling me the guard house is for privacy issues. So, we're going to assess the guard house. Now, the guard house, do we make them also pay for the guard house because of privacy issues based on ability to pay? Or do we say no, no, no, no. Everybody has the same need, need for privacy. And therefore, privacy, everyone pays equally. All right. So, Pishu, I think, personally, I think privacy is privacy. And let's see what he says. But it makes sense to say that everyone has to share equally in a privacy issue. Right? It makes sense to say that when it's privacy, it's not based on a need to pay only. It's based on everyone has the same, I would say, desire for privacy and everyone has the same need for privacy. It's not based on how much money I have. Everyone has the same need for security. No, not necessarily true because I have $25 million in the safe in my house. And the guy next door is $12,000. So, I need the guard more than he needs the guys. So, no, no, no. No, again, he has the bigger need. The guy bigger to the need. Yes. I don't care about the poor guy, go straight to the poor body. He's got a million the whole guy. You're right. But the thief coming from outside the world doesn't know whose house is whose. So, the guy close is not up. First, the guy coming in from the outside, coming guy from the inside is going to attack the first. No, they're going every single house. They're going to their first house first. Their first house first. Yeah. The guy's a killer. He's coming in to kill. Yeah. That's good. So, everyone has the same need to watch. The wolves, he's going to kill the first guy. He can't get to me. He's going to kill the guy over there first. You're right. That's why the security guy will pay equally. They'll pay you. No, they'll pay you. No, they'll pay based on the value. Right. Because he's worth more money. I take this guy and I hold him for ransom. I get more money.