Rabbi Joey Soffer Shiurim
Bava Batra daf 80
Well, good morning everybody. Hi, guys. Hey, John Victor Okay, same thing. Yeah, well, let's go Hello care Pedro Chova. Okay. Well, Mishnah today is September 13th And we are on da'pe in my second Baba Batra Starting new Mishnah top of the page a look here Pedro Chova person what the fruits of the dove coat meaning what the babies what the birds Meja Verro, so I my friend has this dove coat and I'm buying the birds Ma free a hberechari shona You have to leave the first brood See what that means in the Rajbam in a minute. Actually, you know what we'll do it right now. Take a look at the Rajbam I look here Pedro Chova kegon chamalobini son Mejoli pero chanaso mash you she'll do the whole hodish I mean, if I want to buy the the baby birds that are gonna be born in your in your in your in your dove coat for the next 12 months I've a la in my heart locana. You didn't buy the mothers. You only bought the babies Right, but there are you name. This is very interesting since there are you name la a such nev la dot be called hodish Dove's produce two eggs every month Zahar una keba One male one female Hoots me hodish Adarsh and y'all divu except for the month of Adar So 11 out of 12 months you get two eggs from every bird every per month from the mother And each one is one male and one female Okay, the Han who Vladot gamm him was sniff you know hodish in or seem Vladot after the egg hatches two months later those two male and female mate and They produce themselves now starting to produce again every month two eggs one male one female The whole hodish the honey snive Vladot Corine Berecha they call this pair Berecha the two that are born the male and the female eggs that are hatched That's called the Berecha, so he says like this my freya. I'm selling you my Bird my birds that are gonna be born this year in my in my in my oracle my dove coat That means that every female in there is going to give every month to eggs, right one male one female and Therefore I say what many are let throw a him ha em the first pair. I look here I'm pretty sure now, right meaning though the I have to the person who bought the Babies has to leave in the dove coat the first pair that are born many are the throw a him ha em Chiaotan Lomachar the mom needs those two babies She the seller did not sell the first pair why she can't dare come up for him Perot show back I gave Berecha. No, we ought to save it like my heart with cayem. Shova, right? Peña virechua ima hott the hoo shova hoo shova. Oh my God He look at mr. Magam Berecha, I showed us and I saw a kev in my show back. There's oh, he key you much over Says the way you can continue this dove coat to make sure it continues to produce birds Well, you need to have the mother stay if you take the man the mother's first two babies away from her She might leave and she's not gonna produce the next month We don't want that to happen. So the first pair that are born after the deal you leave you get the next month's months Right, that's what he says. Oh bakmaram e farish the gum piro tari shownem. Yeah, he's very sure now She hear a mochair. Let's say that la hach in brecha. She'll not pen Tavra tivra the ha ima lomensaftata the the ha ima lomensaftata Mecha much tivra karishona tivra kamayam, and we're not gonna go into this yet because the gamma is gonna do it So when we get there, you'll see that it's not only the first pair It's also the second pair. He's going a little ahead of himself So we'll get into the banana. We'll talk about it. So back to the michina top. I'll look yeah pero chova havero You bought the bird the bird the birds right that are going to be born in your dove coat this year I leave the first two babies for the seller. He keeps them Okay, Perot Kaverit. I sold the fruits of my beehive Okay, so what is that no tell shaloshani hailim humsares I take three What do you call these the bunch of bees? I don't think all of them swarm. Thank you That's a good word for it. I take three swarms, right? Obisarevs and then I cut them off We have to see what that means in the banana also look at that ashban for a minute Perot Kaver says again shalshana ahat Right this year. I'm going to sell you the fruit the fruits of my beehive this year meaning devorim Hanoladim min hakaverit. I'm selling you the bird the bees that are born into the hive What do I take shaloshani hailim? He says shaloshah haburot three groups. Hanoladot rishona the first three groups that are born Shaloshah is my name me to shi me to shah yamim or asar means they are as a apparently every nine to ten days or so They're the bees are giving birth Shikah shikand then a kaverit. This is how it works But teh bitri lati mottakai it's in the beginning of the summer you're saving a kaverit Nikio should devorim you'll dot shayadu hai mahot Right these baby these baby bees that were born right will leave the hive The yesvin al anaf hai land they go swarm on to a branch someplace Ume vikaverit haddash u machli son the tojo he brings a new right container Whatever he's going to put these this swarm into and these bees settle into there They're gonna soft asarah or tush ayamim you'd say they should devorim our hair from the heart from the original hive another nine ten days later The same thing is gonna happen again. Oh, maybe kaverit a henna trikani to machli son the tokhan the hen chili she Right the same thing happens a third time the corin lot ritz or whatever that word is the yes She or seem a chevash money pamim be me look at them about your band says in Greece Sometimes the hives in the season will do this seven eight times you get these babies Or makutzo where he lives the rash ban, which is France Ruban or seen shosh a pami most of the hives only do this three times in the in the mating season Vashely she garua mikulan de haron haron garua meaning that the Babies that are produced right continue to to be weaker every time So the first one will be the strongest and the second one is weaker and the third one is weaker Hilkach die bish loshan de chilim jonim shanim shanim hashou the men therefore when he said he's got to sell the perot to the babies of this Drive the first three is really what he meant cuz after that they worthless, okay? Umsares what does that mean says that ashban pomami kanba elahi grumble him amokesh i estan esu you're going to cause the bees To be sterile after that below ya asu odd perot kedesh you to dim the asu keen la so to devash husband she or seen devash and or seen blood dot a devash show mocha no She can't get a caver la hashi at school calling a hilim or said vash Yes, or guino to be looking the vase is mentioned medicine or tan the caveratory can it? He says that the bees only produce honey when they're not reproducing They either reproducing or making honey one of the two so once they're done Reproducing after the first three you want to sterilize them so that they stop producing So now they start making honey because when you sold them right the guy who sold these bees didn't sell the honey in the hive And he needs them now he only sold the bees so he sold the bees now He needs the bees that he has still cuz he sold only the babies he wants the one that is still there to produce honey I thought the third group the third group can do nothing They we cut they call me honey either. I don't know. He says they're the weakest. That doesn't mean they can't make honey I don't know. It's just as the day as they they get weaker and weaker It doesn't mean they don't do anything, but so far. That's what they like bomb said not to be not a bee What do you call beekeeper look there? Okay, fine back to the Mishnah? So if I sold the the caverate no tell shalosh on the hilim the first three swarms um sares I cause them according to the ma'am to be sterile hallot vash What if I sold the honeycombs honey hallot vash is the honeycomb from the hive So I sold you the honeycomb of my hive, right? What may me a bit hallot? You're not allowed to Take all the honeycomb from the hive that was that you just bought you have to leave right two Two combs of honey in the original hive. So the guy let's say has a beehive in it has ten honeycombs I sell you I'll sell you the honeycombs of my hive Or you get his eight to the other two never sold to begin with okay That shbam says because those I didn't sell you my beehive that is the sustenance of the bees To continue to live there and to eat that this if I take all the honey out of bees are gonna die So I so I when I saw the honey It's the extra honey that I don't need to keep my this I need to keep my hive regenerating and therefore you don't get those those Stay over here. That's what that ma'am says. Okay. Zetim la kutz if you sold olive trees to cut forward Mein yachte grufiyot you have to leave you have to leave the tree up to meaning you can only cut the place Let's pack it up. You can only cut up to the lowest two branches So you're cutting from the top of the tree down and the lowest two branches is where you have to stop You have to leave the tree with two branches on it. Okay, so anything above that you will have to cut I sold you the tree for wood. I'm allowed to cut up to those I have to leave two branches That's what that ma'am says and we'll see the one about cutting fruit trees and all that stuff when we get there Okay, I just think the bolts of it the tree can get correct exactly We don't want the tree to die it has to keep to enjoy the whole point over here I didn't sell you right I sold it for wood. So I'll write it so therefore I didn't sell you my olives So I always need to grow so all of the trees if it's in the food tree. Yeah, of course Yeah, yeah, but I don't have to talk about it. Why why am I cutting out of olive trees for wood? What's going on over here? Okay, so first in the first part of the mission now Hello cajpero cjóvách is what we said before about the birds about the dust So remember the way that it works is every month you get a pair of birds From the mother one boy one one one boy one girl two months later those four two babies to start mating And they produce and again too much later the brains and all of a sudden before you know it you have a pack a pack to show back All right, so he says they had Tanya cuz it's exponential growth right every month you're getting Hot that I don't understand that that they don't do that in the month of a dark Yeah, I don't know just says it just said for some reason at eleven out of twelve months the the big the dubs mate and I thought they don't make more of them Craziness, right? I don't have the little Google search to see if this is true, but but I'm assuming It could be who knows it's I thought it was for a reason this I don't learn that a lot, but that's what it says It could be I thought it's the last month of the year and he saw this the first month of the years the last month of the year So maybe they're tired Okay, then I tell you Okay, but I toss as follows Berech adi show now who's cnia the first one and the second one Okay, so the mission I said only one When I told you the fruits of my of my dove coat I am allowed to keep the first pair of that are born and then what I thought says the first pair and the second pair I'm on afghana la cashia Ha la ha la ima Okay, I've kind of says no no The Mishnah was talking about the mother bird, right? That had now two babies that you have to leave That's the Mishnah well the female first daughter that was born. She also needs to she needs her first two also so the but I thought saying The mother's the mother with her to and the daughter with her to that's what the but I can't say Okay now my sna my says what time out my sna ima The mid-set the mid-staffed a barta the Azuga the chef kinah la He now me to staff da ima the Azuga the chef kinah la im the chef kinah la it's like this Time out the first the mother bird right the mother bird you say won't leave the nest if her male Mate is there and her daughter at first pair she'll stay So why don't we say by the daughter that she'll also stay with her mate her and her mother Why does she need her kids too right the first mother but I got it. There's nobody there You sold all the birds the mother needs to need to stay in this nest We don't want to disappear so you tell you leave the daughter so the daughter is enough the daughter and hum and her mates her Original mate her husband. That's good. Say the same now for the daughter You know the daughter can have her husband and her mother why she need a daughter also So when I answers back Ima a barta mid-safta right a mother will feel accompanied by her daughter Barta a ima low mix after but a daughter doesn't get the company from her mother. She wants her daughter Okay, fine, and therefore according to the barata which now the moshina is the ma'ana is that when you bought the birds Right, so let's say every bird in there. Let's call it. There's the 10 mothers right so all 10 mothers the first pair you get and The daughter's after those mothers the first pair right all those stay in the head And everything else that's born after that because remember that this is happening every month So it's only the first month that you're keeping after that. They all go to the buyer. Okay, fine Pero covet it. That's the beehive right the beehive Pero I'm telling you the the produce the babies of the of the hive Nautel shaloshan nihailim umsares and then you we said so far according to the bomb said sterilize them It's a bit me said a son. How do you sterilize bees? Oh my god surgery? What am I doing, right? I'm gonna view that I'm a show a little bit hard out you feed them mustard I'm gonna be my arm. I miss me. Did it be or say but it'd be honey not low hot down miss out a son It's not the mustard that actually makes them sterile. They let me talk shit pihan had Hosro to a lot of douchean Because it's the flavor the taste that they have in their mouth the bitter Sharp taste of the mustard that the beads now taste then they go back to the hive and start eating the honey And once they start eating the honey, they stop reproducing Because they're doing it making honey or make your babies. That's it So once they're taught eating the honey the babies the reproduction organs are shutting down and it's over. That's how you do it Okay, fine. Yeah Honey mustard Wow Gentlemen, you're right Victor. I like it. It's good Okay, honey mustard and wonder I wonder if it's a contraceptive Okay Okay, you see everything's in everything's gonna matter everything is there everything is there absolutely That's right That's right Okay The biochen, I'm a no tell shoshan, they're really in busy loose The biochen has a different answer you said see loose means to to write to sterilize There's another way see loose could mean to alternate Right and therefore the biochen, no, no, you don't understand the mission now No tell shoshan if you lean busy loose when you take the three Swarms, it's not number one number two number three. It's one three five alternating swarm two and swarm four stay by the seller and You only get one three and five Bissi loose nickel lean of alternating. That's how you be on on stage the mission now Okay, but not that and I know tell shoshan, he'll imbiz. I'll say me can but a lot no tell a hot man. Yeah, but I try Explaining them this host conversation between the difference of the mission. Ah, and then you know, no, no, they're both right The buyer gets the first three and then starts alternating with the seller so one two and three go to the buyer and then Four goes to the seller five goes to the buyer Six goes to the seller seven goes to the buyer and they keep alternating after that. Okay, fine Halot Vashmin actually halot. Okay, if you bought the honey, you bought the honeycomb. You have to leave at least two in the hive I'm an afkana Drash will cover it and he would say me de maqala le olam Okay The afkana's opinion is that honey inside the hive is considered food Okay, you know, you would say me de maqala le olam the mine afkamina She says what alma kasaba al lo by maqshaba He must understand that honey doesn't need my maqshaba to be considered food. It could receive tuma ah in the hive It's already food Kaq maqsh ma'am from his words, right? So I don't need to even though it's on the tree attached to the ground inside the hive He calls that honey is always food and therefore susceptible to receiving tuma. Okay, meti ved challenge Dvash bikha ver it in a lo achil the lo maqshka Barai tas says that the honey in the hive is not food nor a drink It's neither, which means what is it sounds like it's tree Whatever it is is a food and is it liquid is a liquid is a food Bless you. I'm not about yet. Let's leave a little touch the halot But it's not enough when when we have that statement that the honey in the hive is not a drink or a Food it's talking about the last two that we left in the hive those two honeycombs those are there Olam because we though those are for set aside for the bees. They're not human food They're never gonna be human food because we would never take them out because otherwise we're gonna lose the hive We don't want to do that so those are always going to be considered right those are always considered not food Don't want the less to that we left and therefore when you tell me that you have this but I thought that says the Dvash is not food and not Mashi care. That's the last two that we're talking about those two that are there the Vama a different answer No this but I thought that says in a lo achil the lo maqshka That is the Billy is it he that's the Billy is his opinion which we learned a couple of days back or maybe a week Even did none the Billy as it says as follows kaverit devoreem the Billy is a man. Are you Kekarka the hotel a la crucible? the enemy cabellate to Abimcoma Okay, before I continue that's the piece that we need to talk about our barata because Kavera devoreem this beehive Billy is it says is like land right? It's like land and You can write a crucible right on it for Shmitat to protect your loans And it does not make a bill to our in its place. That's the key. It doesn't make a bill to mine It's place meaning. What is it then it must be a tree. It's attached to the ground All right, so this barata you said eno maqshal and not mashi care the honey in the hive is need of food Nor drink is the Billy is it because he holds that doesn't receive to my role in its place where it is because it's like the tree They had a demi middle be Shabbat if you took the honey out of the hive on Shabbat Hi, I've had thought because that's the same as cutting a tree or taking the apple of the tree It's the same thing the chamomim on reem and could be not a little suppose move in a cacarca Oh, make a bail to Abimcoma. They'll dare measure my patour Okay, and therefore honey disagree with the Billy is it But for our purposes I buy as a valid answer. I mean, who's it that I bought has a valid answer, right? Is it ever? Yeah, I have as a valid answer What's the answer the that barata that says that the honey in the hive is not a drink or food is the Billy is it? Because he could says it like part of the tree I'm at a bill as our my time at the Billy is it what's the Billy is his logic to say that the honey in the hive is like the tree He says dechtiv passuk says vaid bolo toba yarata de Vash Right that he dipped into the forest of honey the Himalayan yar it's a wash Why are we putting the word yar our forest with the next to the honey? Hey, well, I'm a look at ma yarata told us me to be Shabbat Hi, I have had that after the Vash or the village about I have got a table as it says the Torah is teaching you It's pastuk from the from from milachim alif. I think it is maybe from sure is it? I'm shibweh. Where's it from shibweh al alif from shibweh al alif and he's telling you that Just like a person right who takes from the tree tolish from the yar from the forest on Shabbat We'll be high up for our hot hot cuz we did it by Vash or gig so taking honey out of the hive also be high up So gig so you see what that is part of the tree It's the tree and therefore we have two opinions on the table. Rava says that the but I thought that told us before that The the honey in the hive is not a food or a drink is holding like a bealee is it who says what? It's not that honey in the hive is that make I'm able to love him collides like the tree, okay, and Abhaya who told us before know that that but I thought that it's a that it's not food or drink It's talking about the last two honeycombs that you have to leave in there That's not going to be food or drink ever, but the other ones are but the ones the last two are not that's how Abhaya has claimed it So you have my hook in between Abhaya Vrava then let's see right now when I finished yet Métivir We're gonna see what's through that was right. Métivir Devash has Zav mikavarato have honey dripping out of the hive in a low oil Villomashke It's not food and it's not drink now Bishlamala Abhaya Niha Abhaya can explain this but I thought no problem What is it we're talking about the honey that's dripping out of the last two that you often there that we said are not it's not food or drink Yeah, El Niha Abhaya Kasha Niha Abhaya has got a problem, okay, because it I was opinion was That the that the honey that that is in the hive according to Billy Israel is a tree Right and if it drips out, it's not the tree anymore. It should be food, right? But this one says it's still it's still considered low over low much care I'm out of the vid. No Kigonship got shazav. I'll clean my oose Okay, according to that of the vid. You know what happened over here? It dripped on to do into a dirty flow of bowl It never became food. It was unedible. It was tree and now it's dirt Or of aja says about by Akova mark you go and shazav al-gabek kashkashin it landed on Florence So it was tree and now it's thorns. They can't either never food and therefore it's not Had it landed in something that was edible. It was the but I tell it said it's food Okay, may TV try again devash become a rato in a low over low much care That the honey in the hive is not food or drink shishav al-av la achilah metametum at ochlin The mashkin metameh metametum at mashkin But it has his files the honey in the hive is not food or drink if you thought about it that you want to eat it It could not receive tumat ochlin food tumat if you thought about drinking it it can receive liquid tumat That's the bad ata now Bish tumat abaya nicha abaya is okay if I decided that I want my heart my bees anymore And I'm gonna eat those last two honeycombs finish their food. No problem. They can receive tumat That's what Abaya is saying Le rava who says no, no, no the honey in the hive is the tree. It's a tree Kasha if I think about a tree to eat the tree. Does the tree become tameh? Could it be susceptible to receive tumat if I think about an apple that's on the tree and then I'm gonna eat I'm gonna eat that apple and then tumat goes on the apple does the apple become tameh? No, it's attached to the ground. Nothing attached to the ground can become tameh and therefore Rava has a problem with this, but I thought it says that if I thought about it while it's in the tree could still receive tumat El rava Kasha. I'm on the carava. I was is not our tariit Sahi. I'll tell you how to explain this explain this follows He's shev alavla achila Enomitameh tumat ochlin Le machkin Enomitameh tumat machkin Understand the but I try is not the way you want to understand it That's saying that if I thought about it could become tameh Understand that even if I thought about it to eat it still won't become tameh. Why because the stash of the ground Now, that's a little bit hard of a stretch. He's just changing the bada tah round look at those for the top First toast for on top of the page tariits the emah, he he shev alavla achila Enomig yahab bada itah Rava is not changing the text of the bada tah. He's not changing emitameh to Enomitameh. He's not doing that Ela hahikama. This is what he's saying Devash bikavar ato and when you have honey in your hive Eno lo machau, we lo machkin Enyanses shiim shiim shiim la achila shiim Itamitameh tumat ochlin omachkin Right, it says the bada tah said Devash in the kaverit is not machau or not machkin He says, you know, that means it means that even if you thought that you wanted to make it machau That's not machau and even if you thought it was machkin. It's not a machkin That's how he explains the bada. He didn't change the text. Right. Okay Tanya kavateh daraf kahana hegom mr. Kateneh is the hala kah finally devash bikavar ato metamitameh tumat ochlin shiilob imachshaba Okay, the honey in the hive can receive tumat ochlin even without thinking about it, which means it's food It's always in the status of food Okay Now the trees here. We go say team la kuz maybe achte grufiyot We said if I sold you my my olive trees for firewood right for whatever wood building wood whatever you want to do want to make something out of it, right and I am not allowed the person the buyer is not allowed to cut the tree anywhere lower than the less to branches So the lowest two branches on the tree anything above you can cut anything below you're not allowed to cut You have to leave those two branches. That's what the Mishnah said Tanya the banan alokir ela maha verola kuz magbiyam in our kar kahtte fakte kotsets Okay, if you bought a tree, this is not a food tree now There's no matter regular tree and I bought the tree I have to measure one tepach off the ground and I can cut everything above that tepach Okay, but to lata shikma 3 tachim if it's a first-time sycamore never tripped it before I have to leave 3 tachim Sdara shikma that's one that I already trained prior 2 tachim then cut the kannim that's bamboo bigifanim Right, that's a grape grape vines Minap kak olimala right for the first knot. It's in the wood. So bamboo knots. We know what they look like Those knots I leave the first knot cut the rest and there are knots in the wood of the of the of the grape vines Okay, and those I would leave the I believe they're not and I could cut above Bidekalim will be arazim if it's a al-apam tree or cedar tree ho fair or micharesh Okay, you have to dig and uproot You get everything why the fishe en gizan makhleaf Those Don't regenerate the other ones if I left enough room like mentioned above They tree will regenerate or continue to grow but the decal tree or the cedar tree Will not regrow once I cut it and therefore when I bought it, I bought even the roots down I could take both everything with me En gizan makhleaf Ob-tulata shikmaa Shilosha tachim bahinan you told me one minute in this bahrata You just told me that the first time sycamore tree that was never trimmed I have to leave three tachim and then I can cut that's what you told me I read I need three tachim or mini contradiction En kotzitsin bitulata shikmaa bashivi it mipineshi havodah You're not allowed to cut right the sycamore tree in shmitah because that is Avodah for the sycamore tree now, this is I can't trim it at all In shmitah because trimming it is going to make it grow so Wait, tell me it's a three tachim. I could leave even it doesn't even sounds like I could leave I could even more look at a shop that ashban But to latah shikmaa shilosha tachim bit mi hav it's like six lines before the white lines Now a little dive a pahrata. I don't even need three tachim anything Why because he said in the shmitah now let's touch the tree at all Nipineshi of dah shik dal yotih Uchti vichan mecha lautismur so even cutting anything off this tree Right, it will make it grow so even less than three tachim. I should be allowed to cut because it's gonna grow anyway You tell me this thing grows, right? So what do I need to leave three tachim Ermene he ain't cut to see because she can't see what I'm saying. She's about to review dahmer kedar koh asur Ela magbia asarat tachim the quartets or go me me me me me me. I'm a arid's Okay, what does that mean me look at the nashban on the bottom uh Foset And gizmo my place Okay Meaning what we're gonna see he's gonna explain to us right now coming up Which was mina karka ad asarat kat tachim you leave ten tachim will tan kama equal ememar Delait lei hai shi ora Ela shi ora hanina Ke gon michlo sha ulem mala asur the quartets meal amala me asarat He's a cool Allah Allah Allah al makrishor. Okay, back to the rasabra will explain to what we just read The rasabra says like this Ermene he ain't cut to see me too long to shi Baba shi vib eneshi avo dah And bio dawme answer kedar koh asur Right cutting normal. That's not good. What do I have to do magbia asarat tachim I have to move ten tachim up the quartets or go me me me ima arez me ama arez me ama arez with the kashir hai dak mallela Loivante i'm gonna buy a shosha tachim allela No, I'm a man. I'm as bad. I kashir. Let me ima Mother say a lot. Maybe in the flower. What's going on over here? Give me a second. Let's take a look at that aspana Hey What's this ama arez ima arez? What's the program? We keep the ikaka. I'm a man. I'm actually a cook. I love my own. I'm a self-care. This is him in the kashir. He's in my arez He can't be a la me in a karka arez losha or me losha the ad asarat lo makse kashir co kash, we lo yem aale le mizafka la. She doesn't think I shavish you my ale So this some part that I can cut that'll make it okay. So I'm gonna worse. Let me just read this one more time Well, maybe in my older boy. Ella magbia asarat fachim. I have to move up 10 for him the courtsets Oh go ma'am ma'im arez Ma'im arez who the kashir For me close to the ground. That's what's the problem. Ha edach higher than that mallela More than that more further away from the from the ground. That's good So we're talking meaning the first 10th fachim is the problem of course and according to that I mean the buga okay now I got it the buga is saying like this According to the buga 10th fachim the first 10th fachim I have to leave Okay, because under 10th fachim. It's not good for the tree and tenakama who we had before it's not a buga his opinion It's the only three Okay, three fachim is the is is what I would need more than that. I don't need okay now so I mean the ones that are close to the ground the first three or the first 10 depending on opinion holding That's the problem. That's gonna ruin the tree But anything up higher is beneficial to the tree So the but I thought I talked about chemita and it says touching the tree is avodara because the tree is gonna grow and grow Yeah, you're right anything above the 10 According to the view the or above the three according to the cannot is good for the tree You can't do that it should be tough but that's growing the tree when you come at the cell now I didn't sell you the tree that I needed to regenerate you have two opinions the view da verse chakamim is a three or ten But the bottom one is it's not contradictory to the but I thought you told me the mission you told me for why need three twachim And then I could sell the rest and we challenge you what do you need so much Even cutting a little bit is uh is good. It's gonna regenerate anyway. No, no, no, no I'm gonna stand cutting the bottom part. That's gonna kill the tree over there up there. That's the benefit of the tree That's the answer. Okay, fine. Good Um, I'm gonna buy you a short shots for him. I'll let me I'm honest So first of all, you're not supposed to cut the tree altogether number one Not supposed to cut tree unless That's it. Are you doing it beneficial for the tree, which is what we're talking about now I like to grow prudent or The wood is more valuable than the fruit some trees The fruit is nothing. It's a fruit. You could eat it, but the wood's more expensive It's more it's more valuable. So then you're allowed to cut that tree also or it's a new way. You need to do something Right. So okay, fine. Anyway, I'm gonna buy you a short shots for him. I'll let me I'm a man It's but die cashila me candy. I like a little makshila I'm a little makshila. I love him. I love gabish if you eat. I've been in media. They've divided by die cashila Right all on shimita year. I would be allowed to do what's bad for the tree Okay, you can't go gabemek. I don't mean to divide by my allella when it comes to sales I have to do what's good for the tree because I don't want my tree to get ruined. So I have to move away Fine But the calim of it just leave it all together. Well, I'm allowed to do something that's that that's not gonna make the tree grow The problem is is not as more so the car lotus more is the prune so it goes better Otherwise, I'm allowed to I'm allowed to harvest in spita Right I have to eat So I'm allowed to do something a tree that's not gonna make the tree grow. That's not That's not called beneficial for the grounds not planting. It's not true. It's not pruning. So you want to do that for though Right, you want to but I think you want it's a good point that that's different than harming harming sounds more like Maybe I will allow you to do something that's not going to be beneficial to the tree, right? Which is cut it down. I can do that on shimita. I'll have to cut it down on shimita Right, it's not it's not considered farming. It's not farming farming is to make it grow That's the problem with shimita. I'm not allowed to plant not allowed to reap I'm not allowed to prune Right, so cutting the tree down is not pruning the tree pruning the tree is like planting because you make it grow further That's not that's a sort of on shimita, but taking the tree out of the ground no problem be my guess Okay, that's the same as harvesting the wheat. What's the difference, right? Right. I need wood fire. I need firewood and shimita. I can't have uh, I eat in my house. I can't cook it I have to cut. Yeah, okay. Fine Okay But the calimba arazine We said by the before by the palm trees and the sea the trees hofero micharesh Right, you dig and you uproot the wagile vich en gives man gives an makhleaf That's what you told me that the trunk doesn't regenerate So if I sold you the tree I sold everything because I don't need the trunk because it isn't growing anymore So my intention was to give you everything. So you're allowed to dig up with the roots. That's what we said, right? The cedar trees don't regenerate The ha danish ribia balulina my dirty sadik katamari frah Ke eres baliv anon y eske What's this pasuk that we say every week by the way, right? That's sadik, right? We'll sprout like the tamar like the deck here like the palm tree Ke eres baliv anon y eske means to be raised up live anon Lebanon it is cedars like the cedars of Lebanon He will be raised up very tall strong trees right that grow in the mountainous areas high up So the sadik will sprout like the like the deck here like the palm And be as great as this tall cedar trees Imnomar tamar im imar tamar laman imar it is why do the the pasuk switch the macheal in the middle If you're comparing him to a palm tree while you're jumping to a cedar tree The imn imar eres laman imar tamar Let me basically pick one while if it's about cedar, it's about cedar. It's about palm. It's about bombs. Why? What's this pasuk? Right Ilun imar eres velon imar tamar That says if I only called the sadik cedar tree and I didn't call him a palm tree Haidi omeir má eres en ocepero tafsadik en ocepero t Just like a cedar tree doesn't have fruits I would pick the sadik doesn't have fruits if I call this a deca cedar tree. He'll grow no offspring Right and therefore the kahne imar tamar. That's why we said the palm tree the dates Imn imar tamar velon imar eres so then only say the dates Haidi omeir má tamar en gizomah leaf Of sadik en gizomah leaf. I would think just like the palm tree the trunk does not regenerate So to the sadik won't regenerate the kahne imar eres That's why the pasuk called him an eres that he that he will would continue to regenerate He himself can get bigger and grow and grow and more. All right, and even when he sings he can continue to regenerate So the clearly from this denasha cedar trees trunks do regenerate because that's why they were put in the pasuk You told me if I sold my cedar tree the guy can dig up the roots because when I sold it I sold the whole thing because it's not going to regenerate. Well, hello. This says cedar trees regenerate good Okay, my sister's hacha be my askinan illa hacha my askinan Bish army nih anazim No, no this what I ta is told about other types of cedar There are 10 different types if I remember correctly different types of cedar and some of them have regeneration and some of them don't kedra babar of una the amara babar of una amere babar of una amere babar of a amere amere verav Thank you. Asar amine a la zimar of shima. I remember there are 10 types of cedar trees a 10 babid bar eres shita ha das it's shaman eshin And we're going and he keeps on going through this 10 of the people in the pasuk Eres is arza Okay, we can identify them for us which she does help us because we're not badness, but whatever right shita is torita ha das Asa that when we know that's mero. It's shaman. That's a farce man. That's very cool balsam brosh Whatever that one is bart barti tedhar shada tashoor shirvina hani shivat who I said, oh time out Those that that pasuk as only seven. Well, you said this 10 Okay, he utter of demi amara hosifu alahin alunin almunim almugim Okay, they added three more types that are also considered from the cedar family alunim ar butte almunim blute almugim cita So they're what they are We took the english in a minute. Ika d'amre a ronim armonim almugim those are the three that they added on Eronim ari armon ari armonim dulve almugim kissita For there are 10 to therefore the the baari the pasuk that says sadikat amai fla Ke'liz baari armonim gizgeh is told by the type of cedar that trump does regenerate the baari ta that says when you So do you see the tree the guy can upward to tree and dig it out. It's a cedar tree that doesn't regenerate Madokal and I don't I mean I don't know. I don't know the trees so you got to check the english You gotta be a botanist. Yes. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Have a great day guys. Thanks for having me. Not sure about sure (speaks in foreign language)