BiKitzur Shulchan Aruch
Ep. 934. Is One Allowed to Answer אמן (Amen) to a Child's Bracha Even Though They Might Not Be Clean?
Is One Allowed to Answer אמן (Amen) to a Child's Bracha Even Though They Might Not Be Clean?
Welcome everybody, Shinnam on 934, getting back to our Hilchus brochos. Okay, I just want to mention a few of the numerous people from the Sanil Benmash Alibah where Shishibah was at a car accident that had a full of shalomah sukshah, shalomah sukshah holy Israel, of from the Sanil Benmash Alibah, getting back to our Hilchus brochos. Okay, so the question is like this, somebody says, somebody makes a, says a name to a brochah of a young child. Whether it's a bharnach, not bharnach, we spoke about last time a few aunts if the child's bharnach or not, but that's not the issue. The issue is now sometimes the child is dirty, he doesn't clean himself well in the bathroom. So when you're answering a good, so the child made a brochah of Shinnach, whatever, you can't, you know, you can't check every single child every single time, but sometimes a younger child, whatever the case might be, like we said, bharnach, sometimes they didn't clean well and you know, what and the question is, so they made the brochah of the shinnach part and what about answering omah into such a brochah. So it's stuck abroad down the, in the price, can you say, for a lot, let's bring it down on page, and now it's time in Rach test 5. I see a basis as Yish day, it's a mihullam land, it's omah in albirchus cotton, it's a makalikis. Whether you can answer omah in albirchus cotton, shinnach, and a child that's already, let's say, in that case, was already hegih, looking at the, that's already over the age of whatever, 6, 7, because Yish, look at Shillah, kinuach, kinach, atzmaik karoy, that he didn't clean himself well in the bathroom, and possibly there might still be something over there. Then this charmashahoot sai yah befiyat abas, right, like we said, the ane rai levarach, and for an adult, that's a problem making a brochah, but the child, you know, you can't check, like I said, every child, the das harbeach raimim, lahater, so he brings down the many ach raimim, say, it's not a frampay answer, a mane, on such a thing, you know. In other words, the bottom line is, you don't have to be hushish every child, they say a mane, maybe he's still dirty from the bathroom, maybe not, kinuach katim, the atzmaik aina baryachiyova, because the mice of this cotton is not a baryachiyova, he's not over the mitzvahot, or a girl over the basmas for whatever the case might be, the young child, 6, 7, 8, whatever the case is. So he brings down the bottom, it's mbe, he's a small lice, he's on the bottom. I'm not going to run, who wants to be makmir, but then he brings from the ayum shambul vuchay sriradi, brings down the shahikshal dvam, he asks the question of I'm not going to run because of the London sinu, she also ill or say to them, that the fact of somebody's dirty over there from the bathroom, so that's problematic for a person, a regular grownup, right, that somebody over the mitzvah, basmas for a barfiyova, so he is that kasha, and he brings down also the baryachiyova, and so on, why the makmir would be makmir over there, so, so we will be it as it may, that's what he says, he brings from shahikshal sashiv, sashiv, sashiv, vichaym, shakasiv, lahatar, he's also made kome, akhadu lididan, hai tama, kusil, the mice, that area is covered up, anyways, but cotton ba atmaiya and the small child, een a barfiyova, like we said, the cotton is not a barfiyova, it's just the whole thing is all skimmok, all together, okay, the hraloch springs down, there are those who are makmir, we're not going to get into all the different sheeters now, but lomice, he does bring down on the top that, and the mice he brings down, that there is definitely what to be, to rely to, to answer our main and not to be shayshish for those issues, okay, the mice, the piscatu says the same thing, page tough, tough, lama ba atmaiya, our simmirash says vov, the end of oi sashiv, he says vapilu, yadinun chakotun enenaki, even if you know, the mice, we brought down that the minigas, we do say, I mean, even to small children on the day of chinik, but be it as it may, even if you know that the child, he says enenaki, kahai, gimitai, may not be clean from the bathroom, little children, shaapid, dameilani, saminik, is still answering, I mean, alhamdulillani, lama ba atmaiya, and it could be makhannakh, the child, to make brochas, for shaapid, the verb, shaapid, katutya, came into makhannakh, because again, the bottom line is, he being makhannakh, then, and it's not, it's not a real he about them, and even the simmice, yadai, gammla enenaki, agur, okay, and we try and teach them to clean the right way, but, so he says, even makhannakh, enenaki, yadinun, even if you know that the child might not be 100% clean, kimitai, katut, and eir baheu, vamidina, that's, he said, the bottom line, so if it's al-sakhash, for sure, it's no problem, but he says, even if shaapid, enenaki, yadinun, shaapid, you know that he's, not going to be clean, this child is not, he's, whatever, he's, he's learning how to clean in the bathroom, or whatever, the gammla enenya, saya, the fita, ba, saafopi, shaapma, kebis, isil godal, even though for a godal, for a, a, a godal, a grown up over, over the mitzvah, ba, smitzvah, whatever, it's a godal, i feel, ma, ba, mashu, right, mi loin, ba brochat, shaapid, ba, kedushit, that's already a problem, that's a problem for a godal, but when it's al-til child, and it's just al-sakhine, right, so then they say, we say, answering, omni, is fine, and you don't have to withhold, so then you can't teach a child to make brochas, I mean, till he's eight, nine years old, you know, and sometimes even older, depending on, you know, you can't go checking every child, okay, he just does say, on the bottom, he does say on ice 49, if it's a child, in other words, if the child is training, he's learning to go to the bathroom cleaning, whatever, if it's a child, that is the chlau, that is not a bar, he's not holding by, he can't, to be makhannach, and he's under the age of kenach, right, a little child, and he's constantly dirty, so then he says, inlana, i mean, because there were those who said not to say, I mean, anyways, i'll be, i'll go high stuff with the rehako, that everybody holds not to say, i mean, over there, the case that we're talking about, where it's a child, again, it's a, the child is, you know, he knows how to go to the bathroom, he knows how to clean, but, you know, it might not be 100% or whatever, if it's a child that's still not beflal, these things are not negay, or they're still learning, or whatever, the case is very young, and there's a good chance that there's saya, there's extra mint over there, and you know, it's a constant thing type of, he's very young, so therefore, he says not to answer, i mean, inlana, so i'm sorry, so i'm going to everybody, because that's, that's, that's where he's holding, so, again, we're dealing with a child that's at least that much, that he knows, uses the bathroom, cleans, the best he could, and so on, and those cases, so lemise, there is definitely what to rely on, to be able to say, answer, i mean, if somebody feels they don't want to, there are those who were machmir, not to, but, like we saw in the pische chubus, for sure, he says, even if you, dafkenoa, i feel, i feel, i feel you, i feel you, i mean, chakotun, inlana, kahogemitsaya, chape-dame-lana, it's omni nakhabir klesav, uh, mulahanghe, lemibir klesav, you can still be makhannacham to answer brochas, because it's lemise, he's, the child is older, you have to be makhannacham, and he can't wait till it's 100%, thank you for listening us, welcome brochakulta,