BiKitzur Shulchan Aruch
Ep. 937. Answering אמן (Amen) While Davening or Learning.
Answering אמן (Amen) While Davening or Learning.
Welcome everybody, Shinnam and 937. Getting back to our Hilchus Brachus, how are learning shi taka be? Aschus, la rafour, shalaymah, rafour, a rahum, nous sannal, ben masha leba. Getting back to our Hilchus Brachus. Okay, I just want to talk a little bit about something which we spoke about a little bit from the Deershu in reference to somebody's the middle of learning. As far as stopping for a mane, a mane, a mane, haish mirabbi, then what about stopping for bergum? These various different things. Now, I want to make something clear and there's a differentiation. They bring down, ramaish brings in the truth also, and this form bring down that regular a mane, like let's say somebody learning. So if they don't say a mane, so fine. So they're learning, isek, bemitzvah, pataminamitzvah, we're going to see, we'll talk about that. But then there's another thing, if it's a bergum, a person answers bergum, you have to stand up, or at least stand the bow, whatever the case is, my mawidim, your bow, a little bit, if somebody's saying mawidim, mawidim, the ravanan, right? I want to see his kapayim, or these type of things whereby, whereby it's people could see. The problem is not another problem, but people could see, and it becomes like, you know, even though somebody's in the middle of learning, so now it's mikr la colle, he says that's the lotion, nikr la colle, she ain't in mitzvah, if you're mom, that the person good, they're learning very nice, but the person is not mitzvah, if to the rest of the the minion, what's going on? Here everybody's in the middle of mitzvah, kapayim, whatever the case is, right, or by mawidim, or by bergum, so these are, so there's a little bit of a differentiation whereby, if it's only a mane, or even possibly a mane hej marabar, who rosh mawidim for sure, so then it's something whereby people don't see so much, right? So then we could say possibly maybe, oh, it's mitzvah, pada min amitzvah, so we're going to see that there's a distinction. Just to start off, we did do it from the deer shoe, but I just want to go through it a little bit more in detail because it's something that's so important. I mean, all the time, bergum, colle, he's where I was learning taira and you have places, many times you have shoals, many times you have shoals, many times you have other, you know, other places, but you have shoals, a lot of times where there's one minion after another, right, or sometimes you have a few minion going on at one time. So let's say I'm sitting over here in the basement, there's learning and the other room there's a minion, you know, what, what, when and where do I have to answer? Well, let's say I'm in the same room and there's a minion, what, when and where do I have to answer? And there's various different times that come up in a person's the middle of learning or sometimes even the middle of the governing. I'm in with, I know by myself, I'm the middle of the governing. If every time I have to stop and answer, I mean, it gets complicated and I lose the concentration and it's not so simple. So these are things which we want to get into a little bit. So just to start off real quickly and say, for a lot, it's an hour sim and rage test of that's where they bring it down. He said like this, that the age, it's not really brought in rage test. But it's not really brought in the, um, and the mission brew as possible as brought other places. Also, I didn't see it yet, but then we're going to see as we go down the road. But but but our right now, we're trying to stick to our similar race as well, where it's not really brought as far as, um, these are lawless go, but this farm do bring it down over here, meaning that it's a lot, say right? It's a lawless biscuit, which is and so on. So it says like this, the age, I remember the whole mission is a different area. So he says an oyster sign, some that, and he's bringing this from the house. He was the various different, um, you know, place came around him and so on. Okay, so he starts off with, um, saying yes, I mean, the whole mission is a different area. I bet I could make a look, I had to feel it or in their parts of davening. I feel the welcome should look a lot of sick, even in places that, not a milish monaster, but even in places whereby you can even answer, right? Obviously, we notice certain places, you could answer certain things. So even if I'm in such a place, um, but it's going to mix me up, let's say, right? It's part of Milan, it's on main. So the quite a number of, of, um, Aquarium, who want to say that one will be part of from answering, I mean, for culture, came, Lana is part of the Rocha mine. Definitely if we, if, if you put it from saying on main, because you're learning, right? So definitely, definitely, you're going to be part of from saying by Rocha mine, Tom, he's sick, but missful, right? So what's the reason? How is it? Permit, potter, me, mid-face. Okay. But always take the miss for potter, min, a mitzvah. That's basically the concept. Um, and if somebody posts, permit, for, uh, oh, you super miss somebody's, I think one miss was so, so potter, me, mitzvah, acharez, um, in the tradal, the other, if it's going to, you know, if it's going to be hard for him, or, or, or mix him up. Um, now I have to, I do have to say, I once asked, um, I know my Rabbi Rocha on the pearl, so I look with Rocha, and, and I, yes, in the mics, and not with learning, but with dabbening, uh, because of the fact that the middle of dabbening, whatever, it's hard for me to start. People are saying, whatever Rocha is this and that, right? You're in shul, whatever the case is, is there a key for me every time? And we're now, again, we're not talking mocha, so it's a shards, we're not talking about whereby it's a key of the answer. And somebody saying, where's a shards? Where's a shard? I started dabbening ahead. Let's say I'm, say, I'm in the middle of hoidu, I'm in the middle of whatever, acharez, whatever, let's say, uh, whatever the case is, hoidu, mismar, mismar, shir, whatever. And I'm dabbening, and I'm a concentrating. The guy next to me is St. Berchstachecha, so, uh, always the Berchstachella, something along those lines. So I, I know that myself, uh, I get, uh, you know, it's very hard to concentrate every time, stop, go, stop, go, whatever the case is. So I know, I, I, many years ago, I did talk to my Rabbi Rocha on the pearl, so I look with Rocha from reference to that. Um, and he did tell me that, uh, that you could rely on his saka-locha to me who was, at that time, Oisek be mitzvah pataminar mitzvah. That meaning, you know, if, uh, it's going to mess you up, it's very hard to concentrate. Okay. So Oisek be mitzvah pataminar mitzvah, in, in that case, again, but being clear, if it's a question of whereby you have to answer, I mean, like, acharez, acharez, acharez, or whatever, that's a different story, right? You know, the, the person's not supposed to be dabbening back, acharez, acharez, you have to pay attention and answer. As far as learning back, acharez, acharez, we're not going to get into that right now. That's a whole big, uh, different world, but be it as it may. Um, but that was, that was what, uh, by Pearl, um, saka-saka-locha told me that, uh, I used to be mitzvah pataminar mitzvah, it's hard, so, so you don't have to answer and continue dabbening. Um, if it's somebody else, you know, let's say somebody next to you or along those lines. Okay, we're going to stop over here and we'll continue this with sashima upcoming here, and we're going to try and get a little bit into this and see how, how these klallam work. Thank you for listening us, lachum