BiKitzur Shulchan Aruch
Ep. 938. More Halachot in Reference to Answering אמן (Amen) While Learning or Davening.
More Halachot in Reference to Answering אמן (Amen) While Learning or Davening.
Welcome everybody, Shinnam on 938, getting back to our Hils-Kus-Brahas, we're learning today. We're a full Sholem, we're a full of Rahum Nissanal, Ben-Masha-Libah, Shaka'brah, full Sholem Sakhshah, Shae-Shah, Shae-Shah, Shae-Shah, Shae-Shah, Liss-Rall. Okay, we were in the middle of talking about the one should answer middle of learning. Right, again, your person's learning, not if you're learning at home, we're talking about the base medrich, and the person learning the base medrich, or in Shul, and various different types of menion, menion up going on. A lot of Shul sometimes is upstairs, and sometimes you're in a different room altogether, sometimes you're in the same room. Sometimes there's three, four different rooms where menion them are going on. What do I do? I'm learning at this room, this room I'm learning, but there's no minion, but there's a minion downstairs, upstairs, sideways, and I'm hearing a mane. What do I do? I'm in the middle of learning, or in the middle of davening. So, just to read from the Safer Piska Chubus, we started talking about it, I wanted to just go through it a little bit, and again, it's something that applies very, very often - Barch Hashem, which you continue learning Torah. Okay, before we get to that, I want to just read from the, it's actually the Safer Piska Chubus and the Safer Piska Chubus, they quote the same Akranim, which, in general, that we get Akranim said something, and usually they quote basically the same Akranim here and there are a few changes, but he brings them from the H. Lavrami, with Chach, and Piska Chubus also brings them, and I'm just reading from the Safer Akranis, who quotes it a little bit stronger over there, and it's in Ois, again, now with some enraged tests, Vov, and the small Oisius on the bottom, the harvest, Nunn, Gimmel in the middle, he brings it, he says like this, "Coss of the, again, the H. Lavrami, Coss of the whole mash of Miru, the G-gul, Kiyavanius, I mean, we understand that, I mean, it's so great, the Hashemis, the how Homer is the entering of I mean, we have to be so careful, but he says, very important point, Lushayr, again, in conjunction with what's going on, but Lushayr, Bhimee, Chaturid Bhimee, Eun, Obusir, Bhimee, Chaturid, it's not, it's not Lushayr Bhimee, it's, it's, if somebody's learning Chaturid, Tom, the Chaturic, and I get to call him, that's what he's saying, Lushayr Bhimee. Chaturid Bhimee, Eun, Obusir, Bhimee, Chaturid Bhimee, it's not Shire, I'm learning, I'm sitting and learning, it's the greatness of a mane, I understand, but it's not Shire, to me, I'm doing the great thing of learning Chaturid. I feel like Shire, Bhimee, you couldn't stop, you could answer our mane, Bhimee, Kamaqam, Yayishla Padre, the bottom line is like we said last year, Yayishla Padre, Mitam, the person will be Padre, Mitam, Isaac, Mits for Padre, Mits for Sakharis, and this Mits for learning Chaturim is as great as you can get. Okay, so now it says, so that's the bottom line, that, be it as it may, you could you answer, yeah, I mean, Lushayr, you couldn't stop, you couldn't answer. But, like we've been quoting in Saferites Relochis and the Safer Piscat Shupa, it's just to read how he brings it down. Also, on the top of the Mits, the bottom line, and page, tough, tough, tough, tough, test, bottom line, Mits for Isaac, Boulimud, Terre, the Sicha, Boulimud, Terre, I'm learning Terre, I'm learning Terre, I'm learning Terre, I'm learning Terre, Haagam, Shire, Lanes, I mean, you have a Shush, Terre, Terre and Salmin, again, it's not like you're not allowed, Terre and Salmin, you have a Shush, mikomok, I'm Enochive, you don't have to. You don't have to, Imafril, Laiha, Dava, Lurekha is Boulimud, Terre, right? It's going to, it's going to withhold you, it's going to mess you up, or whatever, person's in the middle of something every time to stop, it gets very complicated, and you lose track, you lose trend of thought, where you're up to, and again, the same thing. Well, okay, Enoch, Isaac, Boulimud, Terre and Mitzvah, you're in the middle of a Mitzvah, part of a Mitzvah, okay, fine, so, and then he says, like we said, last time, what was it? Hey, Sifu, let me show you what, didn't have a Spallow, somebody's a Davening also, a female mukom Shmutulah, Habsik, I mean, even though you're in a place where you could make an interruption, to answer, I mean, right, certain times you can't answer, I'm not going to go into all that right now, but you're in a place where you could answer, I mean, but I'm in the middle of Davening, it's going to mix me up, I'm getting all messed up, or you owe me a Tehilamor, Tehilamor, somebody's even saying Tehilamor, Shout, Tehilamor, Tehilamor, Sifu, Shout, Tehilamor, I mean, if it's going to talk every time you stop and answer, I mean, so then one, then we could say, "Oysik bemitzvah, part of minamitzvah," so that's basically the bottom line as to how they bring it down. Now, the, what I wanted to say, the very important thing is, when it comes to Rabim, learning with a Rabim, a Koshikim, brings just a read from the Sifu, "Oysvah, look, Koshik," "Oysik believemitzvah, Tehilamor, the Rabim," if somebody's learning with a Rabim, a Miyit Rabim, Shnayim, even two, even a small Rabim, it doesn't have to be 50 people, right? A hundred people, it's even two, three people. Could go in Shalomah, a chair, and a person's giving a share, but Rabim, we're showing them the Rabim Shabaktusha. So now, good, they're giving somebody's giving a share, and they're here at the Rabim Shabaktusha, some dominion saying Kaddusha, "Oh, there's Barucho," whatever the case is, "Miminyan sammaklahim," this wits close to them. They circle off Siflana, it's that, then, for sure, you don't have to answer. That's even on a higher level, when there's learning Baratam, it's even on a higher level. Now, he does bring down, he brings on the bottom, "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah," "Oysvah, Shabaktushuvah,"