BiKitzur Shulchan Aruch
Ep. 941. More Important Halachot in Reference to When One Is Learning or Davening: When to Answer Amen.
More Important Halachot in Reference to When One Is Learning or Davening: When to Answer Amen.
Welcome everybody, Chinaman 941, getting back to Al-Hilghis Brakhos. Okay, we are in the middle of talking about, of course Al-Hilghis Al-Pameen, some of the rage tests involved. We established the fact that Liz shared, we were talking about reference to entering a main, while somebody is learning Davening and so on, and we said, what we ended off last year, we realized we said that if somebody's, when it comes to the parts of Davening, that it's nicker, like Moidim, just real quickly to read from the Safapiska Chubas, we spoke about Moidim Barkhos and so on, and he says, "Vaniyas, we read it from the Saferays for Al-Hilghis, but we get a better understanding," he says, and he says, "Hey, actually, Vaniyas, a mani haish mihraba bakhlal, that's part of the Batur, in other words, if somebody's in the middle of learning, it's not just a man, but even a mani haish mihraba, they would not have to enter the Khairah." Again, he brings this one from the Saferhil Khashlim, "Avel Qadusha," but when it comes to Qadusha, right, we said when it comes to Qadusha, "Barkhu, Moidim, Bakhmidim, the Siyyas Kapim," standing up by the Siyyas Kapim, the Qahanimad, the Qahanimad, the Qahanimad, the Qahanimad, the Qahanimad, the sustain in front of the Qahanim, as I in Ulamad, the Qahanimad, the Qahanimad, the Qahanimad, if you're in the same room, the Qahanimad is if you're in the same room, we said if it's nicker, right, it's recognizable, that if you're in the same room, then you would have to answer with them now, but he does say, he does answer, he does explain further over there, from the Mihrashlimad, that's the same for Piscatumas, that "Avel Imyush Bakhater Aghar," if somebody's sitting in a different room, right, let's say you're sitting in a different room, but in a different room, "A'hu," nobody could sit there, they don't really see you, right, I'm in the other room, there's a wall, but I can hear everything that's going on, it's right here, (speaks in foreign language) but if you're sitting in another room, I'm learning, I'm learning, I'm sitting in a learning, we're talking about, right, learning in the other room, (speaks in foreign language) is (speaks in foreign language) even from (speaks in foreign language) you would be, (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of learning. (speaks in foreign language) he says even by (speaks in foreign language) I'm sitting in (speaks in foreign language) I'm concentrating on my (speaks in foreign language) so I have to stand up by (speaks in foreign language) so he says, (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) it's an important thing to keep in mind. Now, what he does say, he brings from (speaks in foreign language) he brings from others also (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) if you stand talking to your friend, let's say, (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) then you have to stop (speaks in foreign language) then you have to stop, you have to answer (speaks in foreign language) what do you mean, you have to answer (speaks in foreign language) right, you have to answer (speaks in foreign language) and you have to answer, you have to answer, you can't just not answer. (speaks in foreign language) you have to answer, if you just don't talk to your friend, even he says (speaks in foreign language) could be in your name, (speaks in foreign language) maybe other than, you know, but then you would have to answer, then you would have to answer. It's only over there where by your learning middle, with a robin, there's no nothing to talk about, but if you're in the middle of learning middle of davening, so then all these things you would not have to answer, if you're in another room, if you're in the same room, he said (speaks in foreign language) or remain (speaks in foreign language) you would not have to answer, you could answer, we saw from the (speaks in foreign language) you could answer, but in another room, and not again, in the same room, you would not have to answer (speaks in foreign language) or maybe (speaks in foreign language) again, by learning or by davening, if you're learning or davening and it's going to interrupt you, but the things that are (speaks in foreign language) we said you do have to, right, (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) hey, (speaks in foreign language) it's going to be recognizable to the people, right? So then by (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) all those things you do have to answer, but like he says, if it's in another room, (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) and then people don't see you, if it's a glass wall or something like that, they see you, that's something else, then you would have to also stand up or whatever, but if nobody sees you in the other room, right, there's a wall or whatever, so (speaks in foreign language) the caduce would also be put to, even from caduce, and those other things, because nobody sees you anyways, if, again, if you're learning Daphne, if you're stamp schmoozing than you must, and you're always up there, even a mane, and you may, and you may, and you may, and you may, and you may, and you may, (speaks in foreign language) even in another room, that's not nothing to talk about, right? So that's a different story. (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) is played to (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) even from these things. Again, if you're learning the robin, learning the robin, sort of like, everything goes, as we said, and one has to, one has to, one does not have to stop, one does not suppose to stop. (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) Now, he brings down, okay, so we mentioned the last time the story from the (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) how he brings down where story of the (speaks in foreign language) he told his (speaks in foreign language) when you're learning the robin not to answer, unless it's (speaks in foreign language) unless it's (speaks in foreign language) unless it's (speaks in foreign language) in other words, you're a middle, you're finished off the subject, let's put it like that, and you didn't start the next subject, the next (speaks in foreign language) then that would be fine, but he does bring down another interesting thing, one more quick thing. To keep in mind, (speaks in foreign language) if somebody's saying tell him, you're saying tell him, right, (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) let's see, you come across something, a bed, right in the (speaks in foreign language) whatever you're saying, tell him, and it's not, it's a bed, not that the plastic is bed, but it's saying a bed thing, like a (speaks in foreign language) a curse or whatever, (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) and you hear somebody else saying (speaks in foreign language) then he's saying (speaks in foreign language) then you putter, (speaks in foreign language) then you putter from saying (speaks in foreign language) then you're saying (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) right, you're saying a (speaks in foreign language) you're saying a curse, whatever it is, (speaks in foreign language) or something, a bed, curse, and somebody, whatever the case is, and you hear somebody saying (speaks in foreign language) now you're going to answer a main, it's like you, like you said here a curse and a good, (speaks in foreign language) a main to the curse, (speaks in foreign language) so then he says you would be putter, so that was, it's another interesting thing, whereby one would not say a main, also to their friends, (speaks in foreign language) okay, just send him off the reading from the (speaks in foreign language) that's the same thing, from (speaks in foreign language) he says he brings this from the, (speaks in foreign language) (speaks in foreign language) okay, (speaks in foreign language) so he says (speaks in foreign language) also, (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of learning (speaks in foreign language) so we said (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of learning (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of learning (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of learning (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of learning (speaks in foreign language) and let's say you're learning (speaks in foreign language) something along those lines, right, (speaks in foreign language) and these type of things (speaks in foreign language) at the time you hear (speaks in foreign language) and you're in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language) in the middle of reading (speaks in foreign language)